About a month ago, I was able to nab a pair of these for 60% off from Aloha Rag making them about $56.  I ended up returning the shearling lined ones to Nordstrom since I bought a half size too large.  For Toms I recommend ordering your true size.  I wear 6.5 US and the 6.5 fit perfectly.   The ones I bought are called the Alexandria Classics in black.  I like these because the entire shoe is black including the sole and the fabric is made from a comfy cashmere blend.  Not sure how these will hold up but we'll see.
I think Ashley's outfit below convinced me to get a pair and that they aren't that hideous as described by others. 
|  | 
| Oliver (Plaid), Hayden (Gray), and Alexandria (Black) | 
|  | 
| Ashley in black Toms | 
|  | 
| Ashley wearing gray Toms and MK wearing black | 
source google images "the row toms"
 



